Elston Insurance logo

Want to win a job like this?
This customer received 58 logo designs from 29 designers. They chose this logo design from damian as the winning design.
Join for free Find Design JobsLogo Design Brief
I sell life, disability and critical illness insurance. The name of the company is Elston Insurance, the tag line needs to read "Protect What Matters Most". I've uploaded a sample of what I'm currently using. I would like to use a compass still, but I'm open to other options if you feel so inclined. I definitely don't want a cliche umbrella. My website is www.elstoninsurance.com
The logo needs to be professional, not cartoonish. Less is more.
Updates
Project Deadline Extended
Reason: We're getting closer but not quite there yet. I will message a few of you personally. Still looking for something eye catching and original. A splash of blue color is a good option as well.
Added Thursday, April 24, 2014
Industry/Entity Type
Insurance
Logo Text
Elston Insurance (with tagline Protect What Matters Most)